Skip to content

Blog7 min read

How Spotify playlist pitching actually works

Editorial, algorithmic and independent playlists are three different doors. What each one takes, what a pitching service can and cannot do, and how to tell pitching from payola.

Every week an independent artist pays somebody to "get them on playlists" and receives, a month later, either nothing or a screenshot. The problem is rarely the money. It is that "playlists" means three different things on Spotify, and a service that blurs them is selling you the wrong one.

Three kinds of playlist, three different doors

Editorial playlists are built by Spotify's own editors: Chill Vibes, Lush Lofi, Electronic Rising, the genre and mood lists with the Spotify logo. Nobody outside Spotify can place a track on them. The only door is the pitch form in Spotify for Artists, which your distributor unlocks once the release is delivered and which closes about seven days before the release date. Anyone who tells you they can get you onto an editorial list is either describing that form or lying.

Algorithmic playlists — Discover Weekly, Release Radar, Radio, the autoplay after an album ends — are not curated at all. They are driven by listening data: saves, repeat plays, skips, who else's listeners play your track. You cannot pitch to them. You can only feed them, and the best way to feed them is to be heard by the right listeners early. Which is where the third kind comes in.

Independent playlists are made by people: DJs, bloggers, labels, a person in Lisbon who has kept a downtempo list for nine years. Some have forty followers, some have two hundred thousand. These are the only playlists a pitching service can reach, because they are the only ones with a human at the other end who can be asked.

What a pitch to a curator really is

Stripped of the marketing, a pitch is a message that says: here is a track, here is why it might fit your list, here is a link, no pressure. The curator listens, or does not, and adds it, or does not.

The value of a service is entirely in three things:

  1. Who it sends to. A pitch to a curator whose list does not take your genre is not a pitch; it is spam with a fee. Matching by genre, by hand, is the whole job.
  2. Whether the curator listens. A network where curators are obliged to answer, and to say why on a no, is one where your track was actually heard.
  3. What you get back. Not a number of "submissions" but the answers themselves, which tell you more about the record than any stream count.

Everything else — dashboards, guarantees, "campaign reports" — is packaging.

Pitching versus payola

There is a line in this market, and it is worth being able to see it.

On one side, a service pays curators for their time or gives them tools, and curators add what they choose. On the other, a service pays curators per placement, or lets artists pay for a guaranteed add. The second is payola. Spotify's platform rules treat it as artificial promotion, and the enforcement lands on the track and the artist — removal, stream reset, in some cases the whole profile — not on the company that sold it.

Some signs you are on the wrong side:

  • Guaranteed placements, or a "minimum number of adds".
  • Prices quoted per playlist, scaled by follower count.
  • Playlists whose follower counts are large but whose tracks all have a few hundred plays.
  • No feedback, ever. A no with no reason means nobody listened.

A guarantee is the tell. Nobody who lets curators choose can promise what they will choose.

What good results look like

A realistic outcome for a well-matched track pitched to, say, twelve independent playlists is three or four adds and a handful of useful declines. The adds put the track in front of real listeners in its genre. If those listeners save it and come back, the algorithmic lists start to notice — and that is the effect that outlasts the campaign.

The declines are the part most artists skip and should not. The mix is muddy under 100 Hz. Loved it but it's too fast for this list. The intro takes forty seconds to arrive. Curators hear hundreds of tracks a month; three sentences from them are worth more than most paid feedback.

How Waveforth does it

We are a label first. Cascade Records has pitched its own releases to the same kind of curators since 2009, and Waveforth opens that network to other artists in organic house, downtempo, nu disco and what sits next to them. Every pitch is matched by hand to playlists whose curators declared those genres; every curator listens and answers within a week; every no comes with a reason, and you read it yourself.

We do not sell placements, and we say so on the front page. If you want a guarantee, we are the wrong service. If you want the record heard by people who choose, here is what it costs.

Written by the team at Cascade Records, the Paris label Waveforth works in partnership with.

Your next record is already finished. Send it somewhere.

Upload a track, choose a pack, and watch where it travels. It takes about five minutes to start.